Call for a FREE Consultation: (916) 438-1819

Hablamos Español | Мы говорим по-русски

Call for a FREE Consultation:

(916) 438-1819

Hablamos Español | Мы говорим по-русски

Guarantee: We win, or you don’t pay us a fee!

$400M+
Recovered For Clients

$5.7M
Top PI Result

30+ Years
Litigation Experience

Zero Fee
No Fee Unless We Win

Northern CA
Regional Coverage

Evaluating Bone Fractures, Torn Ligaments, Joint Replacements, and Musculoskeletal Impairment Ratings

THE CRITICAL ROLE OF AN ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY QME

Orthopedic injuries account for most California workers’ compensation claims. From fractured bones and torn knee menisci to rotator cuff tears and damaged joints, musculoskeletal trauma affects workers across every industry. An Orthopedic Surgery Qualified Medical Evaluator is a board-certified orthopedic surgeon trained to assess physical trauma, evaluate the need for surgery, and calculate permanent impairment under the AMA Guides. The orthopedic QME’s findings often serve as the primary medical evidence determining permanent disability compensation and future surgical care.

  • Surgical and Musculoskeletal Expertise: Evaluates bones, joints, ligaments, tendons, and muscles throughout the body.
  • Determining Surgical Necessity: Assesses whether joint replacements, arthroscopic repairs, or reconstructions are warranted under MTUS guidelines.
  • Establishing Causation: Analyzes whether acute trauma or repetitive job duties caused the orthopedic injury.
  • Calculating AMA Impairment: Applies range-of-motion, stability, and surgical outcome criteria to rate Whole Person Impairment.

COMMON ORTHOPEDIC INJURIES EVALUATED

Orthopedic specialists evaluate physical trauma resulting from falls, falling objects, machinery accidents, and heavy lifting.

  • Shoulder Injuries & Rotator Cuff Tears: Full-thickness tendon tears, labral tears, impingement syndrome, and joint instability caused by lifting or falls.
  • Knee Trauma & Meniscal Tears: Meniscus tears, ACL/PCL ligament ruptures, patellar fractures, and joint degeneration requiring total knee arthroplasty.
  • Hip Injuries & Fractures: Acetabular tears, femoral neck fractures, and severe osteoarthritis aggravated by heavy physical labor.
  • Complex Fractures & Crush Trauma: Broken bones in the arms, legs, ankles, and feet requiring open reduction and internal fixation (ORIF) hardware.

AMA GUIDES 5TH EDITION RATING PROTOCOLS FOR ORTHOPEDICS

Permanent impairment for orthopedic injuries is rated primarily under Chapter 16 (Upper Extremities) and Chapter 17 (Lower Extremities) of the AMA Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th Edition. The evaluator applies objective clinical standards to assign a Whole Person Impairment (WPI) score.

  • Range of Motion (ROM) Deficits: Measuring degrees of joint motion using a goniometer and comparing results against standard impairment charts.
  • Joint Stability & Laxity: Assessing ligament laxity in the knees, shoulders, and ankles following tears or surgical reconstructions.
  • Surgical Outcomes & Joint Replacements: Rating joint arthroplasties (knee, hip, shoulder) based on objective surgical results, pain relief, and stability.
  • Muscle Atrophy Measurements: Measuring limb circumference to document objective muscle wasting caused by nerve injury or disuse.

MANAGING APPORTIONMENT TO PRE-EXISTING DEGENERATION

In almost every orthopedic case, insurance adjusters argue that an injured worker’s condition is the result of age-related osteoarthritis, prior sports injuries, or natural degenerative joint disease. Under California Labor Code § 4663, an orthopedic QME cannot apportion disability based on speculative assumptions.

  • Symptomatic vs. Asymptomatic Conditions: A pre-existing degenerative condition that caused no work limitations before the accident cannot be apportioned simply because it appears on an X-ray.
  • Industrial Aggravation Doctrine: Lighting up an asymptomatic arthritic joint into a painful, disabling condition is fully compensable under California law.
  • Substantial Evidence Standard: The evaluating surgeon must explain the precise medical mechanisms and evidence justifying any apportionment to prior conditions.
  • Challenging Apportionment: Your attorney can depose the orthopedic QME to overturn improper deductions that lack objective historical medical support.

WHAT TO EXPECT DURING AN ORTHOPEDIC SURGERY QME EXAM

An orthopedic examination involves physical mobility testing, joint stress evaluations, and an extensive review of diagnostic imaging.

  • Detailed Injury History: Describing the exact forces, falls, or repetitive tasks that caused the musculoskeletal damage.
  • Goniometer Joint Measurements: The doctor measures joint mobility across all planes, recording degrees of flexion, extension, and rotation.
  • Review of Diagnostic Imaging: The evaluator reviews X-rays, MRI scans, and operative surgical reports to verify structural joint changes.
  • Documenting Daily Functional Limits: Explaining how joint stiffness and pain limit your walking distance, lifting ability, and stair navigation.

ACTIONABLE NEXT STEPS AND ORTHOPEDIC QME CHECKLIST

Proper preparation ensures the orthopedic surgeon documents all joint restrictions and objective functional loss.

Immediate Next Step: Gather Orthopedic Imaging

  • Bring copies of all MRI, CT, and X-ray discs directly to the evaluation appointment
  • Gather operative reports from past arthroscopic or open reconstructive surgeries
  • Document specific physical limitations, such as kneeling, overhead reaching, or carrying loads
  • Confirm that the QME panel is certified in Orthopedic Surgery

Administrative Follow-Up: Review the Medical Findings

  • Check that the evaluator documented range of motion and joint stability measurements accurately
  • Verify that Whole Person Impairment was calculated under Chapters 16 or 17 of the AMA Guides
  • Challenge any unverified apportionment to pre-existing degenerative arthritis
  • Consult a workers’ comp attorney to convert the WPI rating into your final permanent disability value

Standing Up for Injured Northern California Workers Since 1996

Musculoskeletal trauma can permanently alter your ability to work and perform daily activities. For 30 years, we have been protecting injured workers. With over $400 million recovered for clients and Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent ratings, our trial attorneys challenge orthopedic evaluators and unfair apportionment, and secure maximum compensation for lasting joint and bone injuries. Consultations are free, backed by our no-win, no-fee guarantee. Call our Midtown Sacramento office today to schedule a no-risk case review: 916-438-1819.

HAVE QUESTIONS ABOUT YOUR CLAIM?

Speak with an experienced attorney today. Get a free, confidential consultation regarding your DWC-1 claim form, denied benefits, or Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) options.

Quick Question Form - Home Page

SACRAMENTO REGION WORKERS’ COMPENSATION COVERAGE
Serving injured workers throughout the greater Sacramento region.
PLACER COUNTY
  • Rocklin
  • Roseville
YOLO COUNTY
SOLANO COUNTY
  • Dixon
  • Fairfield
  • Vacaville
  • Vallejo
NAPA COUNTY
  • Napa
YUBA & SUTTER COUNTIES
SAN JOAQUIN COUNTY (209) 323-5126